Criminal Attorney Oklahoma Defense Lawyer Adam R. Banner OKLAHOMA CRIMINAL DEFENSE ATTORNEY AT LAW

Jury Recommends Death Sentence in Moore Beheading Case


After Alton Nolen beheaded a co-worker and attempted to behead another at Vaughan Foods in Moore, Oklahoma, there was significant concern over his mental competency. Initially, Nolen attempted to plead guilty and asked to be sentenced to death, but a judge was not sure he was mentally competent to enter a guilty plea and refused to accept the plea pending a competency evaluation. When he was deemed competent, he refused to reiterate his guilty plea, and thus, the case went to trial.

Nolen was charged with first degree murder and multiple assault charges. His defense team argued that their client was not guilty by reason of insanity and claimed that Nolen was schizophrenic. However, earlier this month, a Cleveland County Jury found him guilty of all charges against him.

For the five assault charges of which Nolen was convicted, he was sentenced to three life terms plus 130 years (life sentences for three of the convictions, 75 years for the fourth, and 55 years for the fifth). However, before the jury could recommend the death penalty for the murder conviction, they had specific factors to consider.

First, the crime had to meet one or more of several "aggravating factors" in order to make the defendant eligible for the death penalty.

Cleveland County Assistant District Attorney Susan Caswell presented four aggravating factors during closing arguments: whether the defendant had prior violent felonies, whether the defendant was a threat to society, whether the crime was heinous or cruel, and whether there were other people at grave risk of death.

Second, a defendant is not eligible for the death penalty if he or she is mentally retarded. When the insanity defense failed, jurors had to consider whether or not Nolen was intellectually disabled to the extent he could not legally be sentenced to death. During closing arguments

Cleveland County District Attorney Greg Mashburn asked, "Mentally retarded? Really?" He further scoffed, "You don't just become mentally retarded when you're facing the death penalty."

In less than an hour, the jury determined that Nolen was not intellectually disabled. After deliberating nearly three hours, they recommended a death sentence for the murder of Colleen Hufford in 2014.

Formal sentencing is scheduled for December 15.



All News

More News

New Oklahoma Liquor Laws to Take Effect in October


It's summertime in Oklahoma. The temperatures are soaring and peop..

Charges Dismissed After Linebacker's Ex-Girlfriend Admits to Lying About Abuse


San Francisco 49ers linebacker Reuben Foster will be able to rejoi..

Oklahoma Man Convicted of Cyberstalking in Federal Court


A 46-year old Crescent man was convicted in federal court last wee..

Oklahoma Legislators Continue to Eye Criminal Justice Reform


With Oklahoma prisons overcrowded, and with the state at the top o..

Oklahoma Soon to Lead the Nation in Incarceration Rate


As Oklahoma teachers descend upon the state Capitol this week to p..

Domestic Call Ends in Multiple Charges for Man Accused in Standoff


Nicoma Park police and Oklahoma County sheriff's deputies respondi..

Fallin Green Lights Deal for Criminal Justice Reform Laws


Since last year, several criminal justice reform bills have been o..

Law Enforcement as First Responders in Mental Health Crisis


On December 14, 2012, 20-year-old Adam Lanza murdered his mother b..

Weatherford Resident with al Quaeda Ties Attended Chickasha Flight School


A Saudi national living in Weatherford was indicted last week on c..

Actor Awaiting Child Porn Sentencing Found Dead


Former "Glee" actor Mark Salling, who was awaiting sentencing on c..