405-778-4800
Criminal Attorney Oklahoma Defense Lawyer Adam R. Banner OKLAHOMA CRIMINAL DEFENSE ATTORNEY AT LAW
This Attorney is Lead Counsel Rated. Click here for more Information.

Oklahomans Face Murder Charges in Fatal DUI Accidents

09-May-2016

Often, a person who causes a fatal DUI accident in Oklahoma will be charged with first degree manslaughter as a result. Sometimes, however, the charge is not manslaughter, but murder. Last week, two Oklahoma men were charged with second degree murder in separate DUI accidents that left two dead, including a 5-year-old boy.

On Tuesday night, a suspected drunk driver caused two accidents in Tulsa, one of them resulting in the death of a 22-year-old woman. Police reported that around 9:00 p.m., a Ford Fusion driven by Christopher David Mitchell, 27, of Cleveland, struck a motorcycle, throwing both occupants from the vehicle. The driver of the motorcycle and his passenger were subsequently hospitalized in serious but stable condition. 

Rather than stopping, police report, Mitchell continued driving, fleeing the scene eastbound at "a high rate of speed" before crashing into a vehicle making a westbound turn from Saint Francis hospital. The driver of that vehicle was killed in the accident.

Tulsa police arrested Mitchell on Friday morning, booking him into the Tulsa County Jail on complaints of leaving the scene of an injury accident and second degree murder. He remains jailed in lieu of $502,000 bond.

On Thursday, Oklahoma City police arrested Robert Earl Mize II, 35, after a pedestrian accident that killed a 5-year-old boy. Police say Mize was driving without a license after a prior DUI complaint, and there was an active warrant for his arrest following his failure to pay municipal fines in that case. Police alleged Mize, who has prior drug convictions, was in possession of methamphetamine and drug paraphernalia at the time of the accident. He was arrested on complaints of second degree murder, causing an accident without a valid license resulting in death, DUI, possession of a controlled dangerous substance, and possession of drug paraphernalia. He is held without bond in the Oklahoma County Jail.

So why would these two men be charged with murder instead of manslaughter?

Under Oklahoma law, one of the elements of first degree manslaughter is an unintentional death that occurs in the commission of a misdemeanor. Because a first offense of DUI is a misdemeanor in Oklahoma, a large number of DUI fatalities are charged as first degree manslaughter.

However, Oklahoma law includes among its definitions of second degree murder any unintentional homicide that occurs during the commission of a felony other than the violent felonies that would elevate the crime to first degree murder (armed robbery, rape, and first degree burglary, for example). Because a second or subsequent DUI offense is a felony, a repeat DUI offender who causes a fatal accident would be charged with second degree murder, as appears to be the case in the Mize crash.

Reports do not indicate whether or not the Mitchell accident was the result of a repeat DUI, but fleeing the scene of an injury accident is a felony under Oklahoma law. Because Mitchell was allegedly actively committing a felony by fleeing the motorcycle accident when he caused the fatality accident, he was charged with second degree murder rather than manslaughter.

Under Oklahoma law, first degree manslaughter is punishable by a minimum of four years in prison; second degree murder is punishable by 10 years to life.



All News

More News

Catholic Charities Employee Charged with Embezzlement
24-Apr-2017

A Norman woman has been charged with three felony embezzlement cou..

14 Oklahoma Drug Offenders Have Sentences Commuted
17-Apr-2017

Oklahoma Governor Mary Fallin has commuted the sentences of 14 inm..

OKC Man Pleads Guilty to Rape of Child and Murder of Newborn Son
14-Apr-2017

An Oklahoma City man has been sentenced to life plus 20 years in p..

Legislators Pull Felony Drug Possession Bill
10-Apr-2017

When Oklahoma voters filled their ballots in November, they approv..

Former OU Football Player, Cheerleader Arrested for Prostitution
07-Apr-2017

A former University of Oklahoma football player was arrested for a..

Jailer Arrested for Alleged Sexual Contact with Inmates
03-Apr-2017

A Custer County jail employee has been arrested after being accuse..

House Vote Could Allow Internet Providers to Sell Browsing Habits
31-Mar-2017

In a blow to online privacy, the U.S. House of Representatives vot..

Almost Half of Sheriff's Dept. Inventory Unaccounted For
27-Mar-2017

After longtime Oklahoma County Sheriff John Whetsel stepped down, ..

Senate Passes 8 Criminal Justice Reform Bills
24-Mar-2017

In November, Oklahoma voters showed that criminal justice reform w..

Tulsa Man Sentenced in Accidental Stabbing of Toddler
20-Mar-2017

An Oklahoma man accused of throwing a knife at his girlfriend and ..

×