405-778-4800
Criminal Attorney Oklahoma Defense Lawyer Adam R. Banner OKLAHOMA CRIMINAL DEFENSE ATTORNEY AT LAW
This Attorney is Lead Counsel Rated. Click here for more Information.

Oklahoma Death Row Inmate Granted Second Appeal

03-Jan-2014

An Oklahoma death row inmate accused of killing a Putnam City Schools teacher has been granted an appeal by the United States 10th Circuit Court of Appeals.

Bigler Jobe "Bud" Stouffer II was twice convicted of the 1985 murder of third-grade teacher Linda Reaves and the attempted murder of Doug Ivens. Stouffer was dating Ivens's estranged wife, and prosecutors allege he went to the man's home to kill him so his girlfriend, Velva Ivens, would collect a $2 million insurance policy. Doug Ivens survived the shooting and called police, identifying Bud Stouffer as the shooter.

Stouffer first denied being involved in the shooting at all, but later testified that he shot Ivens in self defense after wrestling a gun away from the man. He says that Reaves was either already dead when he arrived at Doug Ivens's home or that she was killed by a ricocheting bullet.

Stouffer was convicted of murder and attempted murder. He was sentenced to life in prison for the attempted murder of Doug Ivens, and he was sentenced to death for the murder of Linda Reaves.

In 1999, a federal appeals court granted an appeal on the basis of ineffective assistance of counsel during Stouffer's first trial. The court found that Stouffer's attorneys demonstrated a "complete lack of skill," agreeing with the Petitioner's claims that the "impression left by counsel's performance was that Mr. Stouffer had no viable defense," and that the defense counsel failed to "exercise the skill, judgment and diligence of a reasonably competent defense attorney."

While Bud Stouffer was granted a re-trial, the conclusion was the same--life in prison for attempted murder and death row for first degree murder.

Now, with the federal appeals court decision, a judge must review the case to see if improper juror communication between an juror and her husband during the trial may have influenced the outcome of the case.

Stouffer's attorney says that he noticed the juror's husband "laughing, joking, handshaking and embracing" a former roommate of Ivens in the courtroom. Furthermore, a deputy testified that he noticed the juror's husband repeatedly nodding and winking at her during the trial and penalty phase as if to indicate agreement with the prosecutor. He said that he also noticed the juror looking at her husband with a questioning look on her face, to which he responded by nodding and rolling his eyes. The deputy testified that this nonverbal communication led him to believe that Stouffer was "screwed."

The trial court ruled that the testimony of Stouffer's defense lawyer and the deputy were not credible evidence of improper communication, but only speculation of improper communication. However, the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals ruled that the nonverbal communication was indeed improper, and ordered that an Oklahoma judge must conduct a hearing to determine whether the improper communication compromised the impartiality of the jury or affected the outcome of the case.

Learn more about criminal appeals here.



All News

More News

Tulsa Tire Store Employee Accused of Sexually Assaulting Customer
17-Jul-2017

An employee of a Tulsa tire store has been arrested on a sexual ba..

Man Sentenced in Shooting of Valley Brook Police Officer
14-Jul-2017

An Oklahoma City man who shot a Valley Brook police officer on New..

No Restrictions on Oklahoma Sex Offender Moving Next Door to Victim
10-Jul-2017

Oklahoma places a lot of residency restrictions on convicted sex o..

Norman Father Arrested in Daughter's Shooting Death
07-Jul-2017

Just before dawn on June 29, a Norman man called 9-1-1 to report t..

Man's Child Abuse Charge Upgraded to Murder
03-Jul-2017

An Oklahoma City man charged with child abuse after his infant nep..

Garvin County Man Sentenced for Sexually Abusing Neighbor
30-Jun-2017

A man convicted in February of sexually assaulting a 5-year-old ne..

Oklahoma Man Accused of Attempting to Kill Cousin, Then Hiring an Escort
26-Jun-2017

An Oklahoma man who allegedly tried to kill his cousin in an arson..

Supreme Court Ruling Says Trademark Law Barring Offensive Names Infringes on Free Speech
23-Jun-2017

You have likely never heard of Asian American rock band the Slants..

Teen Who Urged Boyfriend to Commit Suicide Convicted of Manslaughter
19-Jun-2017

In July 2014, 18-year-old Conrad Roy III attempted to take his own..

Supreme Court to Decide Whether Warrantless Cell Phone Location Search Violates Fourth Amendment
12-Jun-2017

The United States Supreme Court has agreed to hear a case that cou..

×