Criminal Attorney Oklahoma Defense Lawyer Adam R. Banner OKLAHOMA CRIMINAL DEFENSE ATTORNEY AT LAW
This Attorney is Lead Counsel Rated. Click here for more Information.

Not Guilty Verdict in Tulsa Police Shooting; Officer's Job Status under Evaluation


After nine hours of deliberation, a jury returned a verdict of not guilty in the manslaughter trial of Tulsa Police Officer Betty Jo Shelby. Shelby, a 10-year veteran of the police force, was accused of overreacting when she shot Terrence Crutcher, an unarmed man. Prosecutors say Shelby had an irrational fear of harm from the man--a fear that stemmed from racial bias. Crutcher was black; Shelby is white.

However, Shelby's defense team argued that the officer was merely using her training as a police officer, and that she fired upon the unarmed man because she believed he may be reaching for a gun.

The case was complex, particularly given the heated overtones of police shootings involving white officers and black suspects across the nation. Shelby's accusers say that Crutcher had his hands up; they say he was not suspected of any crime, noting that Shelby was responding to a call about a car stopped in the road. They say Crutcher was killed because he was a black man having car trouble.

Shelby's supporters see things differently. Yes, they admit, Crutcher did have his hands up--but then he dropped them. He refused to comply with police commands to stop. He appeared to be under the influence of PCP (a fact later confirmed by toxicology reports). When confronted with police officers with guns and tasers drawn, he dropped his hands and appeared to reach into the open window of a vehicle. Shelby was merely using her police training to meet a perceived lethal threat with equal defense. As her attorney stated, "When someone’s going for lethal, you do not go less lethal.

But the problem facing jurors is that Crutcher was not "going lethal." No one knows why he walked back to his vehicle and refused to stop when ordered to do so by an officer with a gun drawn. No one knows why he apparently reached into the open window of his vehicle. But it wasn't to get a gun. That, we do know. The question jurors had to determine: Was Betty Jo Shelby acting out of an irrational fear when she fired on Terrence Crutcher? Or was she following police protocols in the face of a perceived threat given the totality of the situation?

Jurors deliberated for nine hours before finding Shelby not guilty of second degree manslaughter. The Tulsa Police Union has filed a lawsuit against Tulsa County District Attorney Steve Kunzweiler, saying he violated protocol and caved to media pressure in filing charges against Shelby before police even concluded their investigation and presented their findings to the DA's office. And Officer Shelby's job status is currently under evaluation.

After all, even if a jury found her not guilty, she is still guilty in the eyes of many in the public. She could have a target on her back if she returns to patrol, and if she is involved in a similar situation in the future, her judgement may be clouded by this experience.

All News

More News

Teen Who Urged Boyfriend to Commit Suicide Convicted of Manslaughter

In July 2014, 18-year-old Conrad Roy III attempted to take his own..

Supreme Court to Decide Whether Warrantless Cell Phone Location Search Violates Fourth Amendment

The United States Supreme Court has agreed to hear a case that cou..

Man Sentenced to 4 Years in Stabbing Death of Roommate

A 72-year-old man is ordered to spend four years in prison after s..

Trial Delayed for Second Brother in Broken Arrow Quintuple Murder

Shortly before midnight on July 22, 2015, police in Broken Arrow r..

Criminal Appeals Court Upholds Death Sentence for Triple-Murderer

For the second time, the Oklahoma Court of Criminal Appeals has af..

Poorly written bill leaves lawsuit loophole; Governor signs anyway

When drafting legislation, it is imperative that language is clear..

Not Guilty Verdict in Tulsa Police Shooting; Officer's Job Status under Evaluation

After nine hours of deliberation, a jury returned a verdict o..

Man Exonerated in Rape Case Awarded Compensation

An Oklahoma man who was exonerated of rape after spending 13 years..

Trial Begins in Tulsa Police Shooting Case

Jury selection begins today in the manslaughter case of Tulsa poli..

Oklahoma Death Penalty Remains on Hiatus

It has been almost exactly three years since the botched execution..